‍

You post regularly. You’ve tried carousels, reels, even the occasional behind-the-scenes “raw” photo. You’ve got a solid-looking feed, decent engagement, and maybe even a few viral hits.

But sales? Crickets.

Before you throw your phone into a lake or decide your business "just doesn’t do well on social,” let’s unpack what’s really going on with your organic content — and what to do about it.

The Harsh Truth About Organic Social

Organic reach has been in decline for years. Facebook’s average organic reach is less than 2% of your followers. On Instagram, it hovers around 9%. LinkedIn? Slightly better, but still a struggle if you’re not engaging consistently or don’t have a warm network.

Translation: Even if your content is good, most of your followers aren’t even seeing it.

Source: Hootsuite Social Trends Report 2024, HubSpot’s 2023 State of Marketing

The Real Problem Isn’t the Algorithm — It’s the Strategy

Most small businesses treat organic content like a digital corkboard: post updates, share wins, announce offers, repeat.

But organic social isn’t your sales floor. It’s your front porch.

It’s where strangers peek in, see if you’re interesting, credible, or worth engaging with. And if they like what they see, they might knock. That knock might be a click, a comment, or a follow. Rarely is it a purchase — unless you’ve laid out the rest of the journey.

3 Reasons Your Content Isn’t Converting

1. No Funnel. No Follow-Up. No Sale.

Posting is not a strategy. You need to connect the dots:

• Is there a link in your bio that makes sense?
• Is it going to an optimized landing page?
• Are you collecting emails or retargeting with ads?
  Organic without infrastructure is like fishing without a net.

2. You’re Educating or Entertaining, But Not Positioning

Valuable content is great. But if it doesn’t clarify what you solve, for whom, and why they should trust you over someone else, you’re just giving away free consulting. That’s fine — if your goal is to stay broke.

3. Your Audience Isn’t Ready

If you’re building an audience of creators and posting about how to scale a Shopify store, don’t be surprised when no one bites. Most organic audiences are in the awareness or consideration phase, not purchase-ready. That means your content needs to nurture — and you need a system behind the scenes to warm them up.

How to Fix It

1. Build With Intent

Every post should be a breadcrumb leading to something: a lead magnet, a booking page, a free offer, or a deeper value piece. Stop posting just to “stay active.” Start posting with purpose.

Map your content strategy to each stage of the buyer journey:

• Awareness: Tips, memes, relatable problems
• Consideration: Comparisons, case studies, testimonials
• Decision: Promotions, guarantees, demos, urgency

And no—posting the same carousel on all platforms doesn’t count as a strategy.

‍

2. Use Organic as the Top of Funnel

Organic isn’t dead. It’s just step one. Pair it with:

• Retargeting ads to engaged viewers
• Automated DMs or SMS opt-ins
• Email nurture sequences for lead magnets
  Now you’re not hoping someone buys. You’re guiding them through a system.

3. Optimize for SEO Too

Every caption, every blog share, every YouTube description — it’s all indexable. Most brands forget that social content can improve visibility outside of just the feed. Use the right keywords, link back to your site, and repurpose content into SEO-optimized formats.

Final Thoughts

Organic content isn’t supposed to sell. It’s supposed to spark curiosity, build trust, and move people one step closer to a decision. But that only happens when it’s paired with a real strategy behind the scenes.

If your social content looks good but your sales look flat, let’s take a closer look.

At Digital Marketing Alive, we run complimentary strategy audits that examine your content, your funnel, and your data to give you a real-world breakdown of what’s working — and what’s not. No gimmicks. Just growth.

Book yours today: